The year got off to a terrific start with a wealth of affecting films vying for Oscar glory, settled into one of the worst summers for generic tent poles, and ended with one of the boldest entries in the Star Wars saga.
Yes, it’s that time of year again when movies of the past 12 months are assessed, listed in order of merit then contested by you, dear reader, who wonders why certain films weren’t included. The simple answer is: I didn’t see them all.
Here’s a look back at the good, the bad and the ugly of 2016.
30 Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Zack Snyder took the most anticipated franchise team-up in decades and turned it into an overlong video game cut scene. Mind bogglingly stupid, with Grand Canyon-sized plot holes; a third act twist which made no sense, and Wonder Woman watching trailers for upcoming DC movies on her laptop. And to top it all, Jesse Eisenberg’s Lex Luthor winning my award for most annoying villain in any superhero movie franchise. Ever.
29 Suicide Squad
Margot Robbie stole the show as Harley Quinn in David Ayer’s super villain ensemble. Despite a stunning trailer, the movie turned out to be a huge let down with Jared Leto’s horrible Joker on screen for a thankfully short running time, and the finale feeling like a woeful Ghostbusters remake.
28 The Nice Guys
Russell Crowe and Ryan Gosling were like oil and water in this mismatched buddy crime comedy. Shane Black’s witty script ran out of steam at the end.
27 Warcraft: The Beginning.
Duncan Jones’s ambitious big screen version of the mmorpg was bold but frustrating. A flop in the West, but did well in China so a sequel not entirely off the cards.
26 The Girl on the Train
Emily Blunt could make an adaptation of the phone book work, but this adaptation suffered from a slow second act and proved far less compelling than the source novel.
25 Ghostbusters
Internet trolls ripped the movie apart the minute the trailer was released, so expectations were low. However, the movie was often very funny, with Kate McKinnon a standout as the obligatory zany scientist and Chris Hemsworth a hoot as the team’s gloriously stupid PA.
24 High Rise
The union of star Tom Hiddleston and director Ben Wheatley sounded like a movie made in Heaven. Alas, despite solid turns from Tom and Luke Evans, this was an unpleasant retro mess. Wrong on so many levels.
23 X-Men Apocalypse
Bryan Singer’s CG-heavy fantasy saga rolled on with more top turns from James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender and Jennifer Lawrence. Cinematic candy floss with a couple of memorable scenes.
22 Hail, Caesar!
The Coen brothers essentially made a pilot for a TV series, with two stand out moments: Ralph Fiennes’ “Would that it were so simple” scene (with future Han Solo Alden Ehrenreich), and Channing Tatum’s musical number were terrific. But the open ended finale was just annoying.
21 A Streetcat Named Bob
Trainspotting with a feline saviour. Flawed but touching.
20 Midnight Special
A snail-paced thriller with a good shock (as I was nodding off) and a finale that made it worthwhile. I never need to see it again, but it was bearable. Just.
19 Star Trek Beyond
After JJ Abrams’ powerhouse rebooted Trek offerings, things slowed to impulse power as Kirk, Spock and company tackled another alien warlord who wrecked the Enterprise (again). It wasn’t bad. Sofia Boutella was a standout as the kick-ass heroine, but it failed to reach orbit. Better than The Final Frontier and Nemesis, but could have been something a lot more special. Wherever Beyond is, it fell way short.
18 Jason Bourne
Paul Greengrass and Matt Damon returned to the franchise with a lean, mean crowd pleaser that added little to the saga. There was an inevitable loss, a gruff Hollywood legend to rail against and some hard edged fight scenes and chases. Well crafted but formulaic.
17 Jack Reacher – Never Go Back
Lee Child’s literary hero got a second chance at screen stardom as Tom Cruise helped clear the name of an endangered military type. Cobie Smulders was terrific, there was lots of running and some good fight scenes. That’s about it.
16 Sing Street
One of the best feelgood musical comedies of the year with great songs (Drive It Like You Stole It a standout) and some touching scenes.
15. Captain America: Civil War
Franchise fatigue was starting to set in at the Marvel camp, with their beautifully crafted series of set-ups for The Avengers: Infinity War movies leaving some fans wishing they’d just get in with it. After the humdrum Winter Soldier, this sequel was essentially The Avengers 2.5 as Cap’s team of skilled heroes took on Iron Man’s opposition. A great airport battle was the standout, while Ant-Man and Spider-Man stole the show between them.
14. Doctor Strange
Benedict Cumberbatch was a perfect fit as the arrogant New York surgeon who sought spiritual enlightenment and took on inter dimensional forces of evil. A fun Marvel diversion.
13. Deadpool
Ryan Reynolds’ second turn as the resurrected mercenary (after X-Men Origins: Wolverine) was a foul-mouthed delight and one of the biggest surprise hits of the year.
12. The Hateful Eight
Quentin Tarantino channelled Agatha Christie in a wintry Western shot in glorious 70mm. Cineworld didn’t show it, so it forced me to go elsewhere for what is essentially a stage play, but it was worth the diversion. A twisty turny masterpiece.
11. Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children
Tim Burton’s gloriously bizarre fantasy with a scene stealing Eva Green. An instant cult classic.
10. 10 Cloverfield Lane
Mary Elizabeth Winstead wakes trapped in a room, and as the tale unfolds it turns out John Goodman’s unhinged character has either kidnapped her or is protecting her from something shocking. A three hander with a kicker of an ending helped make this a knockout sleeper hit from the JJ Abrams stable, with superb turns from Winstead and the ever reliable Goodman. And thankfully it had little in common with the shaky cam yawn fest, Cloverfield.
9. Joy
And it was. After Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle, Jennifer Lawrence, Bradley Cooper, Robert De Niro and director David O Russell struck gold again with this tale of a woman selling a mop on QVC. On paper it sounds like commercial suicide, but Lawrence remains the most compelling actress of her generation and made this soar.
8. The Revenant
Leo being savaged by a bear was not the greatest five minutes of film I’ve seen this year, but the epic tale of betrayal and revenge looked amazing, boasted a great cast and though overrated, was still a fine piece of work even if Tom Hardy took incoherence to new levels of Bane-like confusion.
7. Zootroplis
Arguably the best mainstream ’toon of the year was a clever fable/mystery with interesting characters, terrific art direction and a solid story. Little wonder it sold a squillion tickets.
6. The Finest Hours
An old fashioned tale of heroism at sea with Chris Pine on good form as the shy sailor who undertakes a death defying mission to rescue stranded crewmen on a stricken tanker.
5. Anomalisa
A surreal stop motion spin on Being John Malkovich, and plenty of other Charlie Kaufman moments. If featured one of the most touching love scenes of recent years… with puppets. I can only imagine how long it took to make, but the end result was remarkable.
4. Hell or High Water
Jeff Bridges, Chris Pine and the writer of Sicario joined forces to make this splendid contemporary Western set in Texas (which aptly was where I saw it).
3. Eddie the Eagle
Dexter Fletcher’s feelgood biopic of Eddie Edwards, the British downhill skier who overcame the odds to compete for Olympic gold. Sweet, touching and top turns from Tarin Egerton and Hugh Jackman helped make this soar.
2. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
Star Wars Episode 3.5 boasted a great cast, terrific effects and the best third act of the year. It was also the boldest movie of the franchise which added the weight of a star destroyer to a series which has thankfully recovered after those woeful prequels.
1. Arrival
’What if Independence Day was an art house film?’ That’s perhaps the best pitch for this haunting tale of communication with one of the most affecting finales of the year. I was speechless by the twist. Top turns from Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner, while the Johan Johansson score was wonderful. Can’t wait to see how director Denis Villeneuve handles Blade Runner 2049.